Don Murray’s solo on “Blue River” with Jean Goldkette’s band came as a complete surprise. It wasn’t just being used to hearing him on baritone sax with Goldkette and on tenor with Ted Lewis, along with his clarinet in both settings. That would have just made my hearing a tenor sax spot for Murray with Goldkette a novelty.
The sound of this Murray tenor, so rich, so plummy, so far removed from the piping, reedy solos in the instrument’s upper-medium to high registers with Lewis was the real surprise. The first (through about fifth or sixth) time I heard it, it left me scratching my head.
Small wonder since Murray was not even playing tenor sax. Blame my car speakers or blame Murray’s light, transparent as cheesecloth tone on baritone (and thank Albert Haim for educating me):
So many baritone players of this stylistic era played the big horn with a big, burly tone, thick vibrato and percussive articulation. Compare Bobby Davis:
crunching Stump Evans:
massive Cecil Scott (on “Harlem Shuffle“):
bass-sax like Jack Washington:
and the difference becomes clear to the point of world-altering.
Links with Murray’s frequent collaborator Frank Trumbauer are tempting. Yet the C melody saxist’s light timbre dovetails with a light, relaxed approach to improvisation. “Tram” often seems to ease into his lines, even at breakneck tempos. Murray’s approach was rarely easygoing. Even on “Blue River,” his wafer tone spirals into a rapid-fire kineticism. If Trumabuer looks ahead to the cooler sounds of Lester Young And Miles Davis, Murray is firmly, and in hindsight refreshingly, part of The Jazz Age’s nervous energy.
Murray doesn’t cut “Blue River” to ribbons, yet well past paraphrasing it, he turns Joseph Meyer & Alfred Bryan’s repeated note theme into a busy, bouncing ballet of arpeggios, intervals, runs and an ecstatic in-tempo break after the ensemble bridge. His solo is halfway between complete abstraction and the type of recomposition Bix Beiderbecke (here buried in the section) was known for.
Decades of hearing Trumbauer’s own recording of “Blue River,” with Murray in the background and Bix Beiderbecke forever in the foreground, have made it all too familiar to generations of jazz listeners. Murray’s variation resembles cutting lines from Rosencrantz and Guildenstern Are Dead into acts of Hamlet. Goldkette’s arrangement may or may not be as hip as Trumbauer’s but for twenty-four bars Murray makes the tune an event. As for my own naive guesses at Murray’s choice of instrument, I now know better but continue to learn more about this often overlooked player. That’s a jazz musician for you.
I am in a bit of disagreement with Andrew lumping together Bobby Davis with several other bari saxists: “So many baritone players of this stylistic era played the big horn with a big, burly tone, thick vibrato and percussive articulation.”
Andrew cites Bobby’s solo in Spike Hughes’ Poor Butterfly as an example of the big, burly tone. I don’t think so. To my ears, Bobby’s sound is mellow and light. The muted trumpet obbligato by Jack Jackson contrasts with the sweetness of Bobby’s solo, and the flute breaks by Max Farley add an ethereal quality to the proceedings.
I was actually hoping that you would comment on this post, Albert, just because you always have interesting ideas to add to the discussion.
This was not an attempt to stick all of those other baritone players in the same category a part from Murray, but to show varying degrees in one continuum. For me, Davis’s sound is “mellow[er] and ligher[er]” than those other baritone saxophonists. It’s not as dark as the others I mentioned but it is still quite removed from the uniquely transparent sound that Murray has on baritone. It’s funny because I listened to that “Poor Butterfly” several times and was on the fence, but Davis’s vibrato as well as opaque tone (even if it’s not as dense as Carney or Washington) put him a different category…for me.
Like I said, glad you’re here to comment, Albert.
While we’re at it, even Jimmy Dorsey’s bari doesn’t have the crunch and pop of some of those other players, but it’s still very different from the totally unique timbral species of Murray on “Blue River.”